Disclaimer: We are not lawyers and none of the information provided should be taken as legal advice. Statements herein may not reflect the current state of the law and are not intended to provide legal advice, guidance on litigation, or commentary on any pending case or legislation.
Watching crime shows on TV doesn’t make anyone a law expert. It’s essential that you know your rights and when someone is infringing on them. There seems to be a bit of confusion regarding the fourth amendment and RVs. So can police search your RV without a warrant? Let’s find out!
How Do Police Searches Normally Work?
There are many times when law enforcement must have a warrant to search a person or their possessions legally. The 4th Amendment, which protects people from unreasonable searches and seizures, defines these parameters. The key word here is unreasonable, as there are situations that are defined as “reasonable” under this law.
To get a search warrant, a law enforcement officer must typically prove to a neutral third party, like a judge or magistrate, that they have probable cause to search an individual or their dwelling. The officer will provide a sworn written statement (an affidavit) to the third party regarding what they’ve seen or experienced. If the third party believes there is probable cause, they’ll sign off on the request and issue a search warrant.
Law enforcement must prove that they have probable cause that someone committed a crime. However, probable cause can be challenging to prove. Judges and magistrates won’t sign off on every request for a warrant. They must uphold the constitution and ensure they are not violating anyone’s rights.
However, if the officer is given consent to search, a warrantless search may be lawful.
Exception of Motor Vehicles
When we talk about vehicles instead of dwellings, the rules change.
Under the 4th Amendment, “Where there is probable cause to believe that a vehicle contains evidence of a criminal activity, an officer may lawfully search any area of the vehicle in which the evidence might be found.” Arizona v. Gant, 129 S. Ct. 1710 (2009)
A motor vehicle exception was first established by the Supreme Court in 1925 in Carroll v. United States. It allows officers to search a motor vehicle without a warrant if they have probable cause that evidence of criminal activity or contraband is in the vehicle.
It is based in two realms of reasoning. First, there is a lower expectation of privacy in a vehicle due to the regulations they are under for legal operation. Secondly, there is a risk of the easy removal of said evidence and contraband by driving away.
This is where the confusion arises about RVs. Sometimes they are considered “vehicles” and other times where they are considered “dwellings.” Unfortunately, state laws vary on whether RVs can be considered dwellings.
Are RVs Protected By the Fourth Amendment?
The 4th Amendment protects RVs from unreasonable searches and seizures. However, this doesn’t mean law enforcement cannot legally search them.
There are various reasons a police officer could still legally search an RV. It doesn’t matter what RV you’re using. However, they must follow the law and not violate the constitution.
Unfortunately, RV campers fall into a bit of a gray area with search and seizure since they can straddle the line between vehicle and residence. There is no clear-cut answer, and sometimes you won’t truly know the legality of an RV search until all the evidence is heard by a court of law.
Is Your RV Considered a Legal Dwelling?
The US Department of Housing and Urban Development does not classify RVs as legal dwellings. People often see them as temporary living quarters, and the state and local regulations will often prohibit living in them for more than 90 to 180 days.
Many local zoning regulations will restrict the use of RVs, but some areas are stricter than others. Ensure you know the rules and regulations for where you live.
Can Police Legally Search Your RV Without a Warrant?
Yes, police may be able to legally search your RV without a warrant. If the RV is considered a vehicle, it can fall into the motor vehicle exception to the 4th Amendment. However, there have been attempts to distinguish RV campers from vehicles and create guidelines.
Distinguishing RVs from Motor Vehicles
In 1985, the case California v. Carney attempted to create a distinction for RVs under search and seizure. The Supreme Court held that the RV was more characteristic of a vehicle or “place not regularly used for residential purposes.”
The court may use several lines of reasoning to come to a determination of vehicle vs. residence. It may examine situational facts like, “was it on a public road?” If it was on a road versus in a campground or backyard, it more likely was being used as a vehicle and therefore likely subject to inspections as a motor vehicle.
The court may also look at whether the RV is readily mobile. If it could quickly get beyond the reach of the police, evidence of criminal activity and contraband may slip through their fingers.
Finally, is the RV situated in a way that an objective observer would deem it a vehicle or residence? Clues that may impact this would be whether the patio area is set up, if a sun blocker is in the windshield, or if the RV is plugged into power, water, and sewer hookups.
Law enforcement and the judicial system have quite a job drawing these lines. If RVs were simply classified as vehicles, anyone in a campground or living in an RV could be subject to searches without warrants. However, if RV campers are excluded from motor vehicles, criminals could use RVs for all kinds of crimes and not be subject to search without warrants.
Times Your RV May Be Searched Without A Warrant
If the RV is being used as a vehicle, it may be subject to vehicle search laws. These laws allow the search of any area of the vehicle if an officer has probable cause to believe that the RV contains evidence of criminal activity.
Other times that they can search your RV without a warrant includes the use of a narcotics detection dog to walk around the exterior of a vehicle. This sweep does not require reasonable, explainable suspicion. However, if the dog alerts to the presence of an illegal substance, they can then absolutely search your vehicle.
If you are crossing an international border in an RV, you may also be subject to routine search and seizures. Detection dog sweeps are very routine at these crossings.
Generally speaking, however, if your RV is stationary and being used as a dwelling, an officer likely needs a warrant to legally search it.
Granting Consent to Search Your RV
However, if you consent to a search a warrantless search may be lawful regardless of if the RV is in “vehicle mode” or “dwelling mode.”
Law enforcement will often ask permission to search any residence if they suspect something isn’t right.
A police officer asking to search you or your stationary, non-mobile-ready RV may not mean you have to allow them to do so without a warrant. If they want to search you, they’ll have to get a warrant with a judge or magistrate’s signature to complete a search.
If police officers do not have consent to search a stationary RV, they’ll likely need a search warrant. Again, this may depend heavily on the situation and the state laws. They usually must have probable cause and a judge or magistrate to sign and issue the warrant.
If this is the case and they have a search warrant, you’ll have no option other than to let the officers search your camper.
Pro Tip: Want to go on an epic road trip adventure and not get pulled over by the police? This is How to RV Across America: The Ultimate American Dream.
Why Would Police Need to Search Your RV?
Police might need to search your vehicle if they suspect you of a crime or if they arrest you for committing a crime while in the vehicle. Officers may also search an RV if they have reasonable suspicion that illegal activities are happening inside it.
Reasonable suspicion could be abnormal behaviors of an individual attempting to hide something in the vehicle.
Law enforcement has a tough job of protecting the community and keeping illicit substances off the streets. These searches often catch items and help keep everyone safe. However, the police must search your RV legally and reasonably.
What to Do When a Police Officer Pulls You Over
How you handle yourself when an officer pulls you over while driving your RV is crucial. RVs used as motor vehicles usually fall under the motor vehicle exemption and therefore may be searched without a warrant.
If you want to get back on the road as quickly and smoothly as possible, roll your window down and keep your hands visible to the officer. Don’t make any sudden movements and ask permission before reaching for anything.
Be respectful with officers and answer their questions. Many people get nervous when they are pulled over, even if they have nothing to hide. Try to relax and only answer the questions you’re asked. Supplying more information than necessary will likely only prolong the questioning or raise suspicion that you’re lying or hiding something.
How Often Are RVs Pulled Over?
Law enforcement doesn’t pull RVs over any more than other vehicles. Rigs that often attract the most attention aren’t in good condition.
Officers can pull you over for various reasons, but speeding and expired plates are the primary attention-getters from law enforcement. If you are traveling out of your home state, your license plate may also stand out to police officers.
Keep your RV in good condition and follow the rules of the road. You’ll be less likely to attract attention from law enforcement.
Pro Tip: We uncovered If You Are Allowed to Drive Naked to ensure you avoid any awkward run-ins with the police.
Always Know Your Rights As An RV Owner
Ignorance is not an excuse for knowing your rights as an RV owner. Many people have put themselves in challenging situations for not knowing their rights.
However, a good rule of thumb to go by is the situation the RV is in when a search is desired. If you’re driving your RV, you should consider it a vehicle. If you’re stationary, plugged into hookups, and not on the road, you may be able to consider it a dwelling.
Education can protect yourself and your loved ones. However, it’s essential to know that law enforcement has a significant and dangerous job. Most officers will treat you respectfully if you are cooperative and show respect to them.
Do you have additional tips for RVers regarding law enforcement? Let us know in the comments!
Become A Mortons On The Move Insider
Join 10,000+ other adventurers to receive educating, entertaining, and inspiring articles about RV Travel Destinations, RV Gear, and Off-Grid Living to jump-start your adventures today!